As an update, I received a call from Craig from Bobby Archer’s. After Bobby and Craig found out about this post. He stated that they put through the credit this morning, and that this matter was simply an oversight, and a lesson learned for them. I have not as of yet seen the credit back on my credit card, but I will update you folks once I have. Craig has been the only responsive party in all of this, so I appreciate his involvement, he seems to be the intermediary for Bobby and this issue. Whatever Bobby’s lesson learned from this was is his, but I am sure you all know what mine is.
For those who were in doubt, there was only one side to this story, and I presented it accurately and fairly.
Jon
Oh khumba yah my lord, khumba yah …
Before we get all warm and fuzzy inside and believe that Jon’s experience was an isolated case, I have my own experience to share with you all. I only hinted at this and PM’ed (and emailed) several of you. Many of you wondered why I didn’t post some of the details since the Viper community needs to know which vendors/shops are worth our time and which ones are not. Hopefully, I’ll address these and other questions.
First a little background. In July 2004 I had an 'off track incident' in Pueblo, CO. I was there for an SCCA regional event. Long story short is I was thrown off the track in my 01 ACR and ended up impacting into a dirt barrier. Most of the damage was mechanical such as transmission oil cooler, radiator, A/C condensor, tie rod ends, ABS unit, and the steering rack and pinion. The major body damage consisted of radiator support, strut brace bent, driver’s side fender liner, driver’s side sill, driver’s door, minor damage to the hood, a kinked front clip, and one headlight. The car was transported back home to a local dealership July 19, 2004. The body shop at the dealer inspected the car and got it on a frame rack by the end of the week.
The body shop thought the clip could be straightened since it was not torn from the frame welds. They were backed up for several weeks and ran the idea of taking it to a Viper specialist out of town. Most of the recommendations I received were either Woodhouse, Bobby Archer, 3R in Denver and a few others. I decided to go with Bobby Archer and he picked up the car early the next week to take it to Fort Worth. Before the car left town, I took pictures of the damage to the front clip, body etc.
Bobby and I talked about the repairs and we agreed that undamaged used body parts would be fine and if he could save the clip great. A few of the parts were used such as the ABS unit which is very expensive. My concern was to get the car right and in-spec. The car was ‘finished’ Labor Day weekend and it was back in town by Sunday. When I got the car back I noticed what I thought were a few ‘small problems’. So I started a list of things I found that Sunday and prepared a letter to the same local dealer.
Here's the letter I wrote to them detailing the issues I found with the car:
September 7, 2004
Dealer name withheld
Attn. Mr. __________
XXXX _______, NE
Albuquerque, NM 87110
Mr.,
Since I got the car back from Ft. Worth this weekend and having a chance to wash and thoroughly inspect my 2001 ACR Viper here are several issues I found:
- Steering wheel is rotated approximately 1/4 turn to the right when the front wheels are straight.
o Steering rack needs to be centered?
o Car needs alignment? Check tires for wear.
- Air bag light stays on in message center.
- Theft system is inoperable. The car locks and unlocks with the transmitter fob but cannot be armed.
- The repaired hood has several problems. They are:
o Doesn’t latch correctly and is way out of alignment.
o The NACA duct cover is not flush.
o The hood has several marks/scratches.
o The hood has orange peel and was not wet sanded or compounded correctly.
o The hood medallion and decals on both fenders are missing.
- The repaired drivers door has several problems. They are:
o Leaks air/water. The top of the door glass doesn't fit the weather strip correctly.
o The door is out of alignment with the hood and rubs when closing.
o The outer stanchion (glossy exterior black plastic to the rear of the door glass) is scuffed and should be replaced. I don’t think this plastic can be repaired but I may be wrong.
o The drivers door pops open on its own when closed but not locked. Also, the rubber weather stripping is split in several places.
- The replacement front fascia also has several problems. They are:
o The fascia has orange peel and the paint is peeling. I wonder if the painter added rubber compound to the paint before application?
- The rear bumper cover is missing three of the screws on the drivers side rear wheel well and there is a split in the bumper where the middle screw goes. The bumper is very dull which looks like it was buffed through the clear coat.
- The drivers side rear quarter panel is scuffed along the rear wheel well. It actually looks like it was buffed too hard and took some paint off.
- The passenger door has several problems. They are:
o The door is out of alignment and it sticks when opened. The door is starting to tear the door sill weather strip.
o The door is starting to scratch the upper part of the inside of the door.
o The door has various scratches/marks.
o Like the drivers door, the outer stanchion is scuffed and should be repaired/replaced.
- The drivers side rear quarter panel has scratches/marks near the rear wheel well.
- The rear spoiler has various marks/scratches.
- The replaced drivers side door sill (rocker panel) has a 2 inch mark (indentation in paint) in the rear portion of the sill below the door/rear quarter panel seam.
The repairs were performed by
Bobby Archer’s Motorsports Parts & Equipment
1033 N. Henderson Street
Fort Worth, Texas 76107
and their phone numbers are:
(817) 877-1772
FAX (817) 877-5493
1-800-696-0264.
You should deal directly with Bobby Archer.
I do not believe that the repairs to the frame and body included a complete paint job. Those parts that were either replaced or repaired included the drivers door, driver’s side sill, rear bumper cover and the hood. They should have been painted correctly. As you can see, this was not the case. There is rubbing compound/polish in most all the crevices on the car.
My assumption was that the car would be returned 100% mechanically and the body would be free of marks. Mechanically, the car has only a few issues remaining such as the steering wheel alignment, theft system, and air bag light. The biggest issue with the body is alignment of the hood and doors. This is my evaluation and I would like your shop to evaluate the car because you're the pros and I might have missed something.
At this time, I probably cannot afford a complete paint job. Maybe some of the costs that Bobby Archer is responsible for can defray the cost of a new paint job. At a minimum, lets look at blending-in/touching-up those areas that Bobby Archer is not responsible for.
Thank you,
Michael Tobin
(Work)
(Home)
(Mobile)
END OF LETTER ....
And then I get a call from the dealer on Friday on my way home from work that I need to come down to the shop and take a look at the car. What they found, upon further inspection and putting the car on a frame rack, was that the front end was so bad it didn't even register on the rack. I have all the frame measurements after I got the car back from Bobby Archer's. In fact, it looked like they took a 'come along' and tried to pull the front clip back into place. It was so bad that there were tears where the front clip was welded to the main frame. Contacting Bobby proved to be pointless as he dodged me and the service guys here in town for weeks. All I wanted from Bobby was for him to reimburse me for the work that would have to be done to clean up his shoddy work. He wanted the car back so he could inspect the car. Not a chance.
At this point my choices were to hire an attorney since I had all the documentation complete with pictures, frame measurements, sworn statements from over three reputable dealers who would vouch for the shi**y work he did or leave it alone. My attorney also told me to start a log of all calls, faxes that either I made or the dealer made on my behalf in contacting Bobby Archer. I left it alone on the advice of my attorney since he said the only winners were the lawyers.
So I ordered a brand new clip from D-C and had it properly welded to the frame. The total cost to clean up the mess that Archer made was over $7500 and this was a bargain basement price. The guys at the dealership, who are good friends of mine, gave me the 'super bro' discount. It should have been over $10,000. I got the car back in November of 2004 and spent the next several months shaking the car out. This is to be expected since the front end of the car was completely disassembled. The final frame measurements were within +/- 1 mm at the control arms and +/- 2 mm everywhere else. After all this time the car is back to where it was before the accident. And it was done correctly -- no thanks to Bobby Archer.
I have left out a lot of details but you get the idea. Trust me, I have only given the ‘cliff notes’ version. In retrospect, I would have used the local guys from the start or Woodhouse in Nebraska.
So I have and will take every opportunity to let people know the kind of work that is performed at Bobby Archer Motorsports. Whenever people ask for advice on who to go to for repairs I warn them (by PM in the past) about Bobby Archer's. But until now, I haven’t done it publicly on this forum. When the guy runs ads (especially wheels) on eBay I very discreetly warn people. The guy is a great driver but cannot be trusted.
Remarks/Possible questions:
1. Did Bobby Archer do anything correct on my car?
Honestly, the important mechanical items were taken care of satisfactorily. The body/frame work is another matter.
2. Its been over 16 months since my off-track excursion and about 12 months since I had to clean up after Archer’s work – why did you wait so long to come forward?
I decided not to pursue the legal route to compel him to pay me for the extra work I had to do to make the car correct. Angry? Sure I was angry and all it did was make me sick dwelling on it. I mean it ***** the life right out of you. So I re-directed my energy in becoming my car’s caregiver. And she is beautiful.
3. After all this time, was it worth bringing your car back to like new?
Well, all together, it cost me $35K to repair the ACR. She’s as good as before my track excursion. The car is totally back in spec. including the frame and body panel alignment. Most repaired Vipers are not. After all the rework was done, I still found little things that were not quite right. From last November until this past spring I put over 3000 miles on the car to really shake it out. It takes a lot of time and dedication to do this but I would my put the fit and finish of my car up against any other Viper GTS/ACR. In other words, I did my due dilegence but I don’t know if I would ever go through this again. But it was worth it now that everything is worked out and I have just been enjoying riding her these past several months.
4. You have it out for Bobby Archer and made most of this stuff up right?
You can't make this stuff up.