I was in the same boat, having new PS2's on my 17" 5-spokes. The best you can hope for is a used set of older 17" aftermarket rims. I bit the bullet and bought a set of Iforged 18/19" and new PS2's. The problem is if you can find a manufacturer of aftermarket 17" rims, you're spending similar $$ as you would for the larger rims, and the aesthetics still ****.