Who knows if the seats are worn on the 8,000 mile car? Unless abused the 800 mile car’s are NOT.
Using the ebay train of thought we should all buy cars with smashed hoods for $5,000 off and buy a used ebay hood. You can do that with most parts and save money.
How do I know if the transmission has been beat? Ask the 3rd owner if the guys before him did hole shots? What about their cousin who drove the car on the weekends? An inspection does not always find these things on the surface. It’s four moths later when it “keeps popping out of third” and “grinds when it’s cold”. Not a reason to pass on a car with some miles, but if I can get one that is so cherry that it is not even a thought, then I’ll pay more.
The 800 mile car’s maintenance history? You are 100% correct, a low mileage car brings it’s own problems. Buy a warranty and hope for the best. Many 8,000 mile cars have questionable maintenance histories as well
How much would I pay for a perfect 800 mile car? Around $45,000. Gen I that is.
The guy with the 2002 that sold for $10,000 less than new? Well if a 95 R/T was $55,000 new then it got hit $10,000 as well. New cars always depreciate. But wait, his car had 5,000 miles on it, could be cherry, but probably not considered a ****** anymore. Especially with a few mods. I think he did well.
If I buy the 800 mile car and drive it 7,200 miles? Your right it is now a “regular” car and it will depreciate accordingly. And your right the 8,000 mile car will not lose as much value with another 7,200 on it.
Lastly, your right, the two cars will both probably run the same and need the same routine maintenance.
I think I agree with you in principal that a car with some miles is just as good as one that is almost new. Most of your point deals with why some of us will consider a very low mileage car almost new and why when they cross a magic line for miles they are now depreciated and used. Some folks pay a premium for new or as new, some don’t