I had heard that some inexperienced drivers get scared when they feel the pulsing in the brake pedal, then they take their foot off the brake, or pump it, thinking something awful was going on with their brakes. This makes them fail to slow down in time, and they end up braking less quickly than they would if they were in a non-ABS vehicle. I think that was actually a finding,. or maybe a hunch? from an investigator who was reviewing the crash statistics.
This IS similar to what I experienced in my first (and so far only) car that had ABS. I used to have a 97 C5 vette. First time I had to stand up on the brakes to avoid someone stopping short in front of me...damned pedals started jumping under my foot...horrible chattering noise..I though brakes were failing...
I was just more used to having wheels lock up on me...and turning the wheel to avoid if I had to. i had no idea what was going on....found out later that what ABS was all about.
I guess I just don't like them...they feel weird in that I'm not in control of the brakes...locking or releasing as I needed vs having a computer decide for me.
I'm shooting for a Gen 1...and non-ABS is one reason I'd like it. I'm sure I'd get used to it on a newer one...but, just from that past experience..I just don't feel comfortable with ABS....
My $0.02,
cayenne