Chris:
Hmmm, I see, and respect, what you are saying, and I believe my statement was in the interrogatory, to wit "Does it not come down to three factors" (implied "?").
Using your analogy, if the team topples after >decade of winning its divisional title (Eg. Atlanta Braves), then you look for solutions:
a. The often referenced, factory endorsed, aftermarket kit to tide one over until there is a new car
b. An assessment as to whether the team brings more than victories to the fans (Eg. does it create revenue so that the team may continue to even exist?)
c. Is loss a bad thing?
1. I maintain that loss (Atlanta Braves or Dodge Viper) is not inherently bad since it forces those in control to reassess whether they have been approaching the challenge in the most efficacious fashion. Loss can be a powerful wake-up call.
2. Lutz moving to Chebbie was not a governmental secret; it was apparently not deemed a serious threat. However, it was. Or was it not to D-C because this type of winning is not in their game plan any longer. Question, not a statement or hypothesis.
3. Does loss of racing supremecy spell the end of the Viper? If so, it can be assumed that the factory may no longer be valuing that capacity; the trickle down economic effect as to whether a winning Viper sells other Dodge cars. I do not know those statistics. I do know that the Viper made me as an individual look at the rest of their line. However, it did not make me buy.
4. Many teams lose for several years before making a comeback, but fans remain (frustrated but) loyal.
What I was attempting to convey is that this discussion is, has been, and would always be academic. There are some who would jump ship, some who would hang in there, and some who never bought the Viper for racing supremecy...they simply enjoyed owning/driving it. Another VCA Member made reference to that yesterday. i.e. "could not care less; I like my car regardless of what Chebby builds." Amen to that.
I do not know whether a German born executive can move to America during adulthood and find meaning in an American Muscle Car. The Japanese can, the British can, the Dutch can, the Austrian can...but perhaps selling Viper Racing to German engineers and designers as well as their bead counters is not all that viable.
Time will tell.
Thanks for the discussion.
Alice