Initially I thought, great idea. But think about this, if the issue is getting answers to maintenance questions on Gen 1 then you are obviously going to lose all the Gen 2 and Gen 3 guys who have been there and done that with the gen 1 and then moved on. They are not gonna bother to go to that forum and they just MIGHT be the guy with the answer who owned one. I'm a perfect example, I open almost every thread in RT10/GTS and Snake Pit, but I really don't go much to the SRT 10 forum. AND BECAUSE I OPEN ALL OF RT10/GTS I ALWAYS READ A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE GEN 1 PROBLEMS, AND I CONTRBUTE IF I CAN. I don't really think I would open a Gen 1 forum at all. I'm opening individual threads now because I'm not exactly sure what's in them, and I don't wanna miss anything. If I knew it was pure Gen 1, I would not open it. I actually made vehement objections to Tony when we split off RT10/GTS and SRT, and I think I've kinda been vindicated in that observation as we defintely now seem to be split in two groups Gen1/Gen2 guys Vs. Gen 3. It's ALL the Vipernation. I would say go back to Viper General covers all and you will get a lot more participation, interaction and more moving threads. At the same time improve the search function, I think it doesn't work very well and you solve ALL the problems of guys looking for fixes if the search works better. I think it's a search problem not a divided forum problem, the information is all here, it's just hard to find.
There is an interesting comparison here. Corvette forum does divide the cars, but they keep the cars on the same platform together. NCRS, which is ALL the guys restoring ALL the old Corvettes right through C4 to this point does not divide it up at all, they don't want to have anything fall through the cracks. They are maniacs for preserving information and we will be like them some day as our cars age. They actually have every piece of information written in their newsletters (All tech. stuff, no real fluff) and from their site available on disk, somrthing to think about!