The GTI's ride, interior, mpg, looks, value, dsg gearbox (if you opt for it), and ease of being tossed around on days that you want to have mild fun. I would MUCH rather have a comfortable, good looking car than the SRT4 for a four-cyl, fwd hatch.
The SRT4 is better at going fast. But if you want a fast fwd, the only option is the Cobalt SS. The SRT4 needs so much work to be good (it is nowhere near as interesting as the neon SRT4).
Nick
The CSRT has amazingly confortable seats, and theyre not a *** plaid.
Plastic is plastic, no matter how you sugar coat it. Thats like saying this candy coated dog **** is better because it has a candy coating.
I get 33 mpg on the highway and push well over 300 whp. You try 300 whp in a GTI and youll need a new engine soon.
The GTI has a higher value, I agree. However it also costs more. So kind of an equalizing trade off there.
The Getrag 6 speed in the CSRT is bullet proof. 570 whp and counting on the stock tranny.
The CSRT handles just as well as the GTI. People who auto-x their CSRT's beat out AWD platforms, even some porsches. Handling is only as good as the driver.
The CSRT4 has made 570 whp stock internals with a turbo upgrade. The SS/TC can only make around 400 whp on a turbo upgrade.
Also, since u seem to not know, I will educate. For a CSRT4 to run over 400 whp all you need is the following:
exhaust
CAI
injectors
FIC
compressor wheel upgrade
Thats it. That is good for 433 whp / 533 wtq. All stock internals. Hell, you can even keep the stock clutch for a little while on those power levels. Thats without tuning software help. If we COULD tune the CSRT, that car would be a 10 second car. Right now its best run has been 11.6 @ 128 mph.
You try and run those power levels on the stock turbo housing on the SS/TC or the NSRT4 and on stock internals. The NSRT especially would go kaboom on its stock internals. And I can tell you for a FACT that those cars dont have the same 52 mm turbo that comes STOCK on the CSRT.
I know all this information may come as a shocker, but they really dont tell you any of this in the magazines. To be quite honest, the CSRT4 is currently the BEST american sport compact out of the box. It can make the most power at the least cost all on stock components.