The whole concept of comparing sport sedans and sport cars is flawed in my opinion. I don't drive a Viper to haul anyone around in comfort. I didn't buy to car the drive from San Francisco to New York. I don't drive the car because I want and easy, tame, detached, practical, experience while sipping on a latte, rocking Mozart on the 50 speaker sound system. I drive the Viper because the experience is almost all about the car. It is an endeavor that requires concentration, and and being open to the operational nuances of a unique mechanical creation. I want to hear the machine, communicate with it, and attempt to know it, all the while piloting the craft down the unpredictable and inconsistent patch of asphalt of my choice.
I am so tired of people talking up plush and comfortable sedans in the same breath as the somewhat derivative intent of a sports car-- a driver's car. The truth is, any company can make a super quick brick; just add plenty of ponies, a full compliment of nannies, giant brakes, a rigid body, so on , and so forth. Only a few vehicles come along that offer a truly unique (in a good way) driving experience, where looks, performance, pedigree, and "pure driving excitement" come together. Yes, my aging GTS is loud and not overly sophisticated, it is what it is--a sports car that never fails to deliver a broad smile on my face every time I drive it. It will still mash most of the cars out there, and with its brilliantly reliable design philosophy, I can mash on it again and again without much fear of breaking something. Did I mention that the Dodge Viper is a sports car through and through?
I am pleased that the gen 5 can drop the pretenses and be a knuckle dragging sports car; that might be a challenge for a BMW or Mercedes. A fast sedan is...a fast sedan--a cool daily. A fast and shapely sports car / grand tourer is something all together different in my book. These Motor Trend and Road and Track guys almost always have an anti-domestic agenda and a tiresome lack of perspective. Alas, they are entitles to an opinion, I suppose....I don't seem to have a problem forming my own....
(mild rant over)