My Brake Modifications: Hard Lessons Learned by a Cheapskate (LONG !)

RockyTop

Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 11, 2000
Posts
251
Reaction score
0
Location
Roswell, Georgia
In the never ending search for better braking on my 1997 GTS I began the journey I now describe to you in hopes that others will not make the mistakes I did. No doubt I should have done more homework than I did and less listening to speculation by tuners and salesmen. First, I began by buying used Alcon 4 piston front calipers and installing Porsche deflectors (a so-so band aid I am still using; not a substitute for real ducting to the calipers - - not the rotors !), braided lines, Motul 600 fluid and various pads ranging from Hawk Blues (rotor eaters), Porterfield R4 (nice pad, but perhaps not as much bite as later compounds tried), Performance Friction 90 compound (nice compromise race pad). The Alcon calipers came at a good price ($1,700) and I had no complaints, except that my front lock-up symptom just got worse. I then had my tech pull the O-ring in the stock combination valve (which he damaged or tossed - - be careful !) thereby disabling it. The result of this was I seemed to get better rear braking with my stock calipers, but not enough for my liking.

I then longed for more rear braking and listened to a reputable tuner who, upon my inquiry whether I could install my stock Brembo-make front calipers on the rear, said they had done it to a bunch of cars and it worked fine. He said I would need modified knuckles for the rear and so I bought them. I also bought an adjustable proportioning valve from the tuner which (only) restricts/proportions the line to the rear calipers. I then paid to have them installed using the old front rotors in back. Unbeknownst to me, this required the removal of my parking brake. Not a big deal, but a bit of a surprise. Low and behold, when my mechanic went to put my rear wheels back on, there was not enough caliper clearance fore my stock 17 inch wheels. I guess the tuner had never done this on a car with 17 inch wheels (a fact he later admitted).

I was but two days from my next track day and John Purner came to my rescue machining some 1/2" wheel spacers ($25.00) for me and overnighting them to me. Of course no sooner do we get the spacers and try them out (great fit and finish as usual from Mr. Purner !), but my mechanic informs me that me studs are too short. I call the tuner to complain. He scrambles around and supposedly sent me a set of studs that will work, but we'll never know as they never arrived. I was then unable after a literally nationwide search to find studs with the exact knurl size as the Viper requires. It is not a common size.

Nevertheless, I go to Barnett Performance here in Atlanta and get a bunch of 3" Moroso studs with a slightly larger knurl size and my mechanic hogs out the hubs slightly an presses them in. They are of course too long to permit my center caps to be put back on so each has top be cut at its end appx. 1/4-1/2 inch.

Finally, I have the hubs, studs, spacers, calipers rotors etc. on the car and go to drive it home. I test the brakes and experience rear wheel lock up first. F _ _ K ! I then cajole my spouse and 3 kids out to a nearby parking lot to make sure it's the rears locking first, it is (and I have now flat spotted my old MXX3s). Moreover, I am getting right rear lockup only - - a symptom I conclude is due to slight corner weight differences (my car was corner weighted about 9 months ago - -does this ever change by itself I wonder ?).

I call the tuner again and describe my problem and speak to his chief mechanic who informs me it's the lack of the O-ring and that when re-installed that the combination of the stock prop valve and the adjustable valve will do the trick. I scramble around contacting variious folk and a VCA member who happened to have his form his car (which he had sold) overnighted it to me. God I love the VCA ! I have mechainic install the O-ring and bleed iout the system. Guess what. Rear lock-up first !

I then call the unnamed tuner back and speak to his chief mechanic and he tells me I probably have too much rear brake force and may need 6 piston fronts. No sh _t Sherlock, but why didn't this all get discussed at the outset ?!! Moreover, there's no way in heck that (i) I am going to spend that kind of $, and (ii) I sure as heck am not gonna buy them from the unnamed tuner when I do ! However, I have not yet begun to fight. He goes on to suggest that I try street pads in the rear. I buy a slightly used set ($100) from Sean Roe (who once again comes through in the clutch for me though he's very skeptical it's gonna work). Sean suggests I might also try a more aggressive compound in front like the PFC 01 compound. I call and speak with a PFC rep and he concurs it should help, but he's skeptical in light of the comparable piston diameters I now have in the front (1 7/8" and 1 3/4") compared to the rears (1.65" and 1.5"). He was very helpful though.

I have the pads installed and try my braking test again. D_ _ n! I am still getting rear lock-up first. I call the unnamed tuner again and speak to his chief mechanic who suggests that I chip off 1/2" on each end of each of the rear brake pads thus reducing area. GTS Dean is very skeptical (and to this day has not said I told you so - thanks Dean). You guessed it, it didn't solve my problem. The guy at PFC says it won't since it's a force thing more that a surface area thing. All I probably did was increase the heat on the remaining pad surface.

It's time once again for a day at RoadAtlanta. This time I experienced way more pedal travel due to the larger capacity of the rear calipers. Heel-toe is a thing of the past no matter what in the hard braking zones due to pedal travel. I then buy a bigger master cylinder from Sean Roe and got that fixed fine ! Nice high hard pedal with good modulation ability. The prop valve has been dialed all the way out (to the least amount of line pressure) since the day I brought it home. It might serve as a better paper weight !


As I had boiled brand new Motul 600 the last two times I was out at VIR and RoadAtlanta, I tried the AP 600 fluid at Dean's suggestion. Great stuff ! I won't go back to Motul - which wasn't bad, but the AP is better.

SO, WHAT HAVE I LEARNED ? 1. Let the guys like Roe, Stop Tech, Brembo etc. do your research unless you have more patience than I do. 2. The PFC 01 compound is excellent ! 3. AP 600 is great fluid (but flush out all the old stuff before you change). 4. Don't be afraid of math. Comparing my total piston sizes front to rear I have about a 53.5% to 46.5% front to rear bias. It's not way off with my pad compound band aids, but I still get rear first lock up and flat spotted the heck out of my nearly trashed rear Hoosiers last time out - great James Bond smoke screen coming into 10A at RoadAtlanta though ! It's harder to feel the rears lock up because you do not get the nose-dive visual cue like when the fronts do it. Don't worry, I did all my hard braking in a straight line and still nearly got into two Porsches (I hate them for their brakes) ! 5. I am now left with the choice of going back to the ****** stock rear calipers (or something slightly larger - more $) or going to 6 piston front calipers (way more $). I have concluded to go back to stock in the rear and repull the O-ring. UNCLE !!
 

cstegall

Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 20, 2001
Posts
933
Reaction score
0
Location
Fort Worth, Texas USA
RockyTop,

Whew! Your situation/experience must have been totally frustrating. I have been toying with changing the brake system on my 01 GTS and have been watching the various Viper owners talk about their situations on the board. Yours definitely takes the "don't give up" award! After reading about your efforts I think I will just stick with the stock system(I have,however,added an Archer Ducted brake cooling system) and if all else fails I will just pop open the door and drag my feet.. ala Fred Flintstone style!

Thanks for your informative story...

C Stegall
 

ACR Joe

Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 6, 2000
Posts
843
Reaction score
0
Location
Newtown, PA
That is a friggen nightmare. I too have been anxious to upgrade my brakes and intend to reference a long running and current string on this topic. I may ultimately refrain from any mods whatsoever.

RockyTop ..... my sympathies!
 

Ron

Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 6, 2000
Posts
2,137
Reaction score
1
Location
Indianapolis
A sad but enjoyable read. Thanks for sharing your experience, I'm sure many will learn from it.
 

Gavin

Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 15, 2000
Posts
431
Reaction score
0
Location
Monterey, Ca, USA
ACRJOE I beleive you can upgrade you brakes and do so with confidence - This very detailed report from ROCKYTOP simply tells you two things;
1. WHEN DOING A BRAKE UPGRADE - DON'T TRY TO DO IT ON THE CHEAP
2. CONSULT THE FOLKS MENTIONED IN HIS POST - THEY DO KNOW OF WHAT THEY SPEAK.

I upgraded the brakes on my 96GTS (Sean Roe Package - you couldn't ask to deal with a more helpful supplier - he is great) I have run 5 to 6 thousand miles on the street and several open track events - I am very comfortable with this setup - please note - go to any of the upgrade setups and stock rotors are going to get chewed up pretty quick - I warped the first set after two open track weekends and into of the first day of the third I had dozens of tiny cracks forming.

Now- thanks to guys stepping in and helping out with a new set of rotors I learned something- FREEZING THE ROTORS - same freezing technique as used for freezing "human bodies" - the term escapes me - Ted May and others can help here I'm sure.
This reportedly increases the life of the stock rotor substantially.

Enough rambling - do your homework - talk to the various suppliers - find out from you clubmates what upgrades they have chosen- don't be cheap and by no means does that mean you have to buy the most expensive option - luck
 

Viperrick

Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 8, 2000
Posts
469
Reaction score
0
Location
Illinois, USA
Gavin. the freezing term is Cryogenic treatment. Involves freezing and baking. The process is to realign the molecular structure of the material being treated. Has anyone proof? Does this really work in extending the life of the rotors?
 
OP
OP
R

RockyTop

Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 11, 2000
Posts
251
Reaction score
0
Location
Roswell, Georgia
GTzViper

I suspect that the Baer rotors you refer to are of Alcon make and they are VERY expensive. They are supposedly cryogenically treated (which Carroll Smith says works). However, for the cost ($800+ per pair), I can buy like 3 sets of the Colemans mentioned below. The best route for relatively inexpensive discs is to get Coleman to make some for you. Call Essex Parts Services at (770) 889-4096. They'll need one of your old rotors, but they can do floating hat setups, slotting, cross drilling (don't bother), just discs or whatever you want. The brake tech guy there (whose name I have forgotten) is very good. I bought some Coleman replacement dics for my Baer/Alcon fronts (13.5" x 1.25") from the unnamed tuner and I know he got them through Coleman.

If you really want better braking performance, first upgrade to stickier tire compound, lose 20 lbs then work from there ! ;^)

P.S. When the tech at the dealer put my new replacement rotors on he left off the shims that are used to position the brake calipers relative to the rotors so one rubbed and warped one of my new discs. I found a new have a new tech !
 

GTS Dean

Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 22, 2000
Posts
3,915
Reaction score
305
Location
New Braunfels, Texas
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by RockyTop:
Moreover, I am getting right rear lockup only - - a symptom I conclude is due to slight corner weight differences (my car was corner weighted about 9 months ago - -does this ever change by itself I wonder ?).

<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

It can change, but usually not by much. The big question is: Did your car get corner-weighted with driver ballast in the seat, or was it empty? If you drive a lot with 2 people in the car, then corner-weighting empty isn't so bad. If you track the car solo, then 200 or so pounds of left side weight will make a noticeable difference.

For a given effective brake radius, brake torque is a function of piston force and lining coefficient of friction at a specific temperature. Bigger pads just wear longer.
 

JonB

Legacy\Supporting Vendor
Supporting Vendor
Joined
Dec 8, 1997
Posts
10,325
Reaction score
45
Location
Columbia River Gorge
Very informative post. Worth archiving in the symptom/diagnosis area. OOPS..... we still dont have one.

Grassroots motorsports have always involved garage dabblers and hackers.....sometimes with good, but usually mediocre result. Going to school on companies who have done their homework, and examples like RockyTop are the best lesson. [But you STILL select non-floating (warping) Coleman cheepies in lieu of true floating (no-warp) StopTechs or Baer Eradispeeds?]

Here in PAC-NW, PartsRack helps sponsor the T-1 GTS of Cardic Racing. Roger experimented w/ cryo-rotors (SCCA mandates OE rotors) and did achieve 20% longer rotor life. However, they are so cheap (and sponsored by us) that why bother w/ the expense? About $50 / pair to cryo...25% of OE rotor cost!
 

ElDiablo Viper

Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 3, 2001
Posts
2,105
Reaction score
0
Location
Pomona, NY
I have cryo treated rotors. What it means they freeze them and then heat them up. This makes them more resistant to warping (which stock vette rotors are known for).
 

Sean Roe

Supporting Vendor
Supporting Vendor
Joined
Sep 19, 2000
Posts
1,714
Reaction score
0
Location
Jacksonville, FL
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by JonB - PartsRack:
......[But you STILL select non-floating (warping) Coleman cheepies in lieu of true floating (no-warp) StopTechs or Baer Eradispeeds?]
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

Jon,
I don't know if you've had some sort of bad personal experience with Coleman, but mine's been good with them. Coleman makes a nice product (not cheap) and we've been using their rotors on race cars since 1993. They offer solid OR floating mount rotors and hats. I've used both styles and am happy with the solid mounts.
I've talked with the overseas company that makes the rotors for Baer/ Eradispeed. They're fine too. I'd still use a Coleman on the track (better cooling fin design moves more air and they're lighter).
My personal upgrade choice from a Coleman would be a Performance Friction Rotor. They outperform the Brembo, Alcon, etc. and are becoming widely used in pro racing. The same set was used by ORECA for the full 24 hours the year the Viper won overall at Daytona.


<FONT COLOR="#ff0000" SIZE="1" FACE="Verdana, Arial">This message has been edited by Sean Roe on 12-12-2001 at 04:28 PM</font>
 

Bob Woodhouse

Enthusiast
Joined
May 2, 2000
Posts
222
Reaction score
10
Location
Fort Worth, Tx.
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by RockyTop:
5. I am now left with the choice of going back to the ****** stock rear calipers (or something slightly larger - more $) or going to 6 piston front calipers (way more $). I have concluded to go back to stock in the rear and repull the O-ring. UNCLE !!
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

Wow, Rocky, you sure took a long way to get where you are. But hold the fort man, you got all the ingredients close enuf to right. Do not spend any more money. All that is necessary is for you to install an adjustable proportioning valve in the rear brake line. Maybe you already did this, I got confused. Do not re-install the O-ring, and leave your front calipers on the rear. Then go do your skid tests and continue adjusting (reducing)the rear pressure till you have the balance you want. This will give you a pretty darn good street/track set up. We have done this install several times and we are familiar with the math, with moving calipers, with the two different sizes of master cylinders on stock Vipers, with Alcon,Stop Tec and Brake Man, you are just a couple of turns away from a killer brake system. If you need me or our staff 800 889 1893
 

Latest posts

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
153,645
Posts
1,685,216
Members
18,221
Latest member
tractor1996
Top