My 2 cents.. (which is worth more then other peoples 2 cents
)
1st .. I have had in my arsenal a 2002 ACR, 2005 Stock and 2006 Paxton Coupe. I have personally put over 80,000 miles through these 3 vipers.
Here is honest to god feedback from a guy who would actually know, and has drag raced them all:
1. gen 2s have better tires stock for stock. Ditch the run craps and you'll see the difference. Hell even get ps2's and your tires will be BETTER then stock gen 2's (ps1s arnt as good as ps2s).
2. gen 2s have better WHEELS stock for stock. We are running a damn 19 inch stock rear on gen 3s, that means we effectively have a HIGHER gear ratio then thee gen 2s even if you didnt add to it with the 345/30s being even yet still a slightly taller tire then the 335/30s that the gen 2s have (sure we get a slightly bigger patch too, but being that we have run craps, its of little value). So they have 18 inch wheels with 335/30 tires, we have 19 inch wheels with 345/30 tires. Again our power has a mechanical dissadvantage to theirs at turning the wheels (size vs size).
3. Gen 2's have a better posi then the gen 3s... HOWEVER at drag racing, if you get the tires hot enough, this becomes less critical, as you will get both tires to dig in, and the posi will do an effective job at DRAG RACING.. not so great at road racing, but thats not what this post is about.
4. gen 3s are LIGHTER then gen 2s, so we most certainly on paper have the power to weight advantage. and I believe we have a slightly better CD (coefficient of drag).. So why dont we destroy them ?? 50 more hp, lighter weight, better CD ?? Simple... see #5.
5. gen 2 pcms are BETTER then gen 3s when it comes to consistency. Our F'in gen 3 pcms decide to screw us when the heat starts coming on in a gen 3. A gen 2, just keeps you pretty consisten, up until you over heat.. (lol). The gen 3s pcm is protecting us against over heating and pinging (05+), a gen 2 pcm cares a lot less about over heating and nothing about pinging. I consistenly could hot lap the Sheet outta my gen 2, and nail 11.50's one right after the other... set your clock by it... but my gen 3, I could get 11.50's only within a small window.. and this is it.: Car needed to sit after arriving at the track... about an hour would be suffiecent at most, then get in line, keep the car off and cool until I got to the burn out box, do a nice burn out, until you see smoke coming off the tires(any more then that, and your show-boating) get to the light, screw the etiquet of you light up one, he lights up one, then you light up the other.. you just get there and pray he hurrys the hell up (if your racing someone else). Then Launch the car between 1700-2300 (at most on street tires), roll ******* the throttle, but not too hard that your spinning your times away. Run that Bee-atch up to 6000 and SHIFT quickly (there is more there in the rpms so dont PRE-EMPT the fuel shut off by trying to shift at 5900, because you think in 100 more rpms fuel cut off will occur. I believe it actually happens at 6250. So again, hit 6000 and pop the next gear. I run this thing through ALL 4 gears... run out 1st, 2nd and 3rd and go right into forth, even if there is only 10 feet left (its more you just dont know it) between you and crossing over the line. Running out 3rd never worked for me, i always hit fuel cut off, and always seemed like the car wanted to unload more of that bottem end torque, begging for me to go into 4th before finishing the run.
If the car didnt get to hot (and most likely it did), you can quickly get right back to the stagging area, and try again. That really is the #1 problem with the gen 3s is that damn pcm doesnt like for the car to get hot, once temps climb it seems to be either taking out timing, or adding more fuel (aka rich and fat, and lower power). The gen 2s dont do this anywhere as bad.
Gen 2's you can "hot lap them" and that lets you do something significant... learn its shift points and its launch. A gen 3 will screw with you if you hot lap it, becasue if you try to learn your launch or your shift points, your doing it with a power delivery system (engine) thats constantly varing how much power its going to give you. Get a gen 2 hot, and it still pretty much delivers that same power within a range of + or - 20 degrees. (195-215).
If the 03 and 04s are "making more power" then 05 and 06, its because of the pcms. I think the pcms got more "woosy" in 05 and 06, again favoring more heat protection then power delivery.
Jon