F355 - You may have had an "underpump" situation. If you filled in Jersey, most likely you did not pump the gas. The tank may not have been fully filled to start. The next pump may have had a lower threshold for sensing vapors and may have pumped all the way up and then some. If you did some calcs using this type of situation, you may have not had good mileage. If I were you, go with the obvious here before swapping parts out and the like. Do another tank fill, but then return to the same station, the same pump to get a more accurate reading on the actual gas used between fill-ups. Of course, you can check the tire pressure as that is quick and easy. Use Hess gas in your area as it is refined near you and is not a fly by night outfit.