NY TIMES: Our Towns
A New York Dodge Dealer and His Legacy
You must be registered for see images attach
Librado Romero/The New York Times
Chuck Tator at work at his Dodge dealership in South Salem, N.Y., a business his grandfather started in 1914.
By
PETER APPLEBOME
Published: May 16, 2009
SOUTH SALEM, N.Y.
Skip to next paragraph Related
Tator's Dodge Web Site
Enlarge This Image
You must be registered for see images attach
The dealership in 1919.
On Nov. 14, 1914, John and Horace Dodge, two bicycle makers turned automotive pioneers, began selling their first cars as the Dodge Brothers Motor Car Company.
The Dodge reputation was so great that thousands of people applied for the first dealerships. Twenty-five were chosen. No. 3 on the list was George T. Tator, an automobile mechanic in a rural slice of Westchester County, who managed to scrape together $800 and a horse to buy four and a half acres with a house and a barn outside South Salem.
In his first year he sold seven of the very first crop of $785 Dodges, using the barn as his garage and office and three horse stalls as bays for the cars. The next year he sold 12, and the year after that 20. Three years after it started, Dodge Brothers Motor Car Company was the fourth-largest automobile manufacturer in the country, and by the late 1920s, Mr. Tator and the five associate dealers now working under him were selling 250 cars a year.
Even then, the auto business could be a tumultuous one. Sales plummeted with the Depression and never surpassed their peaks in the 1920s. The Dodge brothers both died of flu in 1920. Five years later, their widows sold the company to the New York investment firm of Dillon Read & Company for the astonishing sum of $146 million. Walter
Chrysler bought the company in 1928 for $170 million and since then it’s lived on as a Chrysler brand, its origins, for 99 percent of consumers, lost in the mists of time.
But if the corporate history got complicated, the Tator history became part of the fabric of local life and American myth. Mr. Tator took a damaged Dodge truck and added two 30-gallon soda and acid tanks to it, and it became the town’s first fire truck. The Fire Department kept its equipment at the dealership until 1953, mechanics dropping wrenches and jumping on the truck when there was a call.
Under George Tator, his son Charles and now Charles’s son, Chuck, it became a local institution the way car dealerships became part of the landscape in towns across the country.
Annual sales climbed to about 100 in the late 1940s and 1950s and then steadily declined as newer dealerships were established, and as buyers began moving away from American cars. Now 30 is a good year. But Tator’s managed to survive not just as a local institution but, improbably, as an international one. Chuck Tator, who still lives above the dealership, became known as one of the most proficient service people for Dodge Vipers, the $90,000 10-cylinder sports cars lusted after by car aficionados.
“He’s one of the absolute masters, the guy to go to on the whole Eastern seaboard, Canada or Europe,” said Scott Grayson, former president of the Viper owners club for New York and Connecticut. “And he’s old-school in the best way, like a doctor who makes house calls.”
Of those 25 original Dodge dealers, all but a handful are gone. Only one, Tator’s Dodge, is still owned by the original family. It’s like an automotive museum, decades of parts filed away, the vintage Coke machine, the original cash register, the ancient Sealed Power Piston Rings clock and the red neon Red Ram V8 neon sign, the emerald green 1953 Windsor Deluxe sedan that hasn’t been driven for five years.
But history gets you only so far. Chrysler’s financial arm tried to cut off Mr. Tator’s ability to buy and sell cars two years ago and backed down when Viper owners went ballistic. And last week, when the list of the dealerships that would be terminated was released, Tator’s was on it. A company spokeswoman said it was an unpleasant situation for everyone, but with sales plummeting there had to be a consistent standard.
“It was a data-driven matrix that took in eight or nine different things,” said the spokeswoman, Kathy Graham.
Mr. Tator is still flummoxed. He figures 95 years of history should count for something, and cutting off his dealership, and its ability to service cars under warranty, will not help anyone. “They won’t save money by cutting me off; they’ll lose money,” he said. “I’ll bet you 90 percent of my customers would go to a different brand if they couldn’t buy from me. I think the company has lost sight of what the customer wants.”
He plans to make his case to the judge handling Chrysler’s bankruptcy and figures he’ll stay in business as a repair garage, almost certainly keeping most of the Viper business no matter what.
You can look at the 95 years and see this as one more, particularly wrenching, bit of automotive tumult. You can look at the 95 years and see this as the end of an era. But you can’t look at it and think Dodge or Chrysler or whatever name ends up on whatever cars gains anything by cutting its ties to Tator’s Dodge and one last link to the days when Americans were good at making and selling things made of chrome and steel, not securitized bundles of numbers and nonsense.