It doesn't have
anything to do with the looks, IMHO. What it does have everything to do with is distribution and execution. Let's look at both a little more objectively than beating the "NASCAR" and "lost the looks" drum:
DISTRIBUTION
First off, they are simply building too many. In 2002, the last year you could possibly buy a "classic" Viper design (RT/10 or GTS), DC built all of 1463 cars total. That is only 545 RT/10's and 918 GTS/ACR's - including the 360 Final Editions. For all the looks of those cars, they weren't huge sellers in total volume. Also note that the vast majority went to actual Viper dealers and were preordered. In other words, they sold most of them before they left the factory. Thus the number of supply days was minimal.
Now in 2004, they built 2435 Vipers and every single last one of them was the same bodystyle: The SRT-10. Only in 1994 did Viper production exceed that number, and that was largely because the car was in great demand and only 1300 were built in the first two years combined. And how were those 2435 Vipers distributed in 2004? No preorders necessary, they were sold to any Dodge dealer willing to put one on the lot. And no reason to preorder them as a consumer, they only came in three flavors. With so many dealers able to get one for the very first time, they jumped all over it. Result? They are sitting with a car on their lot that exceeds the income of 99.9999% of their residents. They either don't sell (thus your excessive supply days), or the dealer panics and dumps the car on eBay or elsewhere. That results in a glut of "underpriced" cars that further screws up the market. Many forego a reputable Viper dealer so they can buy it wholesale from JoeBobHenryJoe's Spiffy Car Lot. The result is that even MORE cars are sitting on the lots unsold.
The bottom line on distribution is that by building them in excess without the extensive preorders, you were already dooming yourself. Throw in the fact that they were available to pretty much any dealer, and your fate was sealed. Do you think the perceived value of a Rolex would drop a bit if they were produced in bigger numbers and sold through Walmart? Extreme analogy, but you get the basic idea.
EXECUTION
Besides our regular detractors on the looks department, I get a LOT of people that say they like the looks of the SRT-10 more than previous models - even though I don't (as compared to the GTS). It is indeed more mainstream looking (less exciting) and just a hair more civilized. Designed (GASP!!) more for the Corvette crowd than the original Viper crowd. And why not? The idea was obviously to sell more of them than previous models, thus the misconceived idea of mass production combined with mass distribution.
The problem is that you have now placed the Viper in a precarious position: It is far more expensive than the Corvette and the upcoming Z06. It is much less exclusive (and less exciting) than the "new" Ford GT. You basically have two things at work: Power-to-dollar ratio (Vette wins) and dollar to exclusivity ratio (Ford GT, Murcielago, and many others win). You simply can't "mass produce" a totally impractical car that stickers closed to $100,000. You can argue that the AMG products are more practical in that they can be driven by anybody in any weather (as can the Vette) and often seat four people. The Viper, even in the more civilized SRT-10 version, can't. Hell, just about every other sports or exotic car made is easier to drive than the Viper. That is it's attraction for few and that is it's curse for most. Forget mass production.
Let's not forget that you are building the EXACT same car over and over and over and over....... There is no Coupe variation and dammit, there is no real color variation. Sure, they made 200 White Mambas and
you can't find a new one for sale. Why? It was a limited, one-year color. Did they announce white as a production color when they quickly sold out? Nope! But what about those
suckers that plopped down some big bucks for the "exclusive" yellow VCA Editions? Surprise! They announce "Viper Yellow" for the exact same year of production. Not smart. Even white would have been better for 2005, because those 2004 White Mambas are still totally unique to that year.
Besides red, can you name the color that was produced for three years straight on the Gen II? NONE. Let's go down the list of colors and the number of years they were produced in a row. Hell, let's add the total number of cars produced during that time as well:
Gen I
Emerald Green - 2 years, 440 built
Bright yellow (Gen I) - 2 years, 381 built
White - 1 year, 324 built (1996 - technically Gen 1.5)
Black - 4 years, 1547 built (includes 1996, as the GTS was not available in black that year)
Red - 5 years, 4026 built (also includes 1996 as red was not a GTS option then)
Gen II
Sapphire Blue - 1 year, 545 built
White (GT2) - 1 year, 100 built
Graphite - 1 year, 406 built
Steel Gray - 1 year, 673 built
Silver - 2 years, 415 built in 1998 (build numbers not available for 1999)
Black - 2 years, 605 built in 2000 (build numbers not available for 1999)
Yellow - 2 years, 1074 built
Blue - 2 years, 2181 built
Red (1997-2002) - 6 years, 3163 built (not including 1999 as no numbers were available for that year)
Gen III
Black - 3 years and counting, 1308 built (not including 2005)
Red - 3 years and counting, 1882 built (not including 2005)
Silver - 3 years and supposedly done, 906 built (not including 2005)
White - 1 year, 200 built
Yellow - ???, ???
Whew!! The point? It is that by the time you add in interior options and stripe options for the Gen II's, pretty much every "variation" is more rare than the SRT-10's -
in just two years of production. Even the black Gen I RT/10's that were produced for four years straight are outnumbered by the black SRT-10's - in half the time. The bottom line is that not only is DC attempting to mass produce an exotic car, but they have "watered down" the entire concept of rarity by leaving no factory options available and sticking with all of the same colors. "Mamba Editions"? Great idea if the exterior color is unique for that year, like the white. But announce exactly 200 of a custom interior on a car that is otherwise the same as 3000 others, and the "rarity" isn't all that special - especially when the numbers are announced in advance. Hell, I love my VCA SRT-10 but I shudder to think when DC starts churning out 2005 SRT-10's in yellow by the boatload. Gee, thanks a lot DC.
Don't get me wrong, I LOVE my SRT-10. But mass producing it with little or no variation takes away the "exotic" appeal of the Viper, especially when yahoo dealers are throwing them on eBay because they can't carry the note.
Gee, I guess I should have summarized that in the beginning rather than here at the end of this long-winded rant...